58A Black Toner(No Chip), for HP M404 M404n/dn/dw MFP M428/M428dw/fdw, W258A
This page is affiliate-supported. Prices and availability can change after the last marketplace refresh.
About this product
This Oosder 58A black toner cartridge (W258A) is a compatible standard-yield option for HP LaserJet Pro M404 series (M404n/dn/dw) and MFP M428 series (M428dw/fdw, M428fdn) printers, including the M304. It's a laser print technology cartridge that is specifically advertised as having "No Chip" in the title, although the specs also mention "WITH CHIP." The cartridge offers a page output of up to 3,000 pages and is backed by a 3-year manufacturer warranty.
Our take
As a reviewer, this Oosder 58A black toner cartridge presents a significant point of confusion due to the conflicting information regarding the chip. The title clearly states "No Chip," while the "CHIP" spec lists "WITH CHIP." This ambiguity is critical, as a chip is typically necessary for proper printer function and recognition. If it truly comes without a chip, users would need to transfer one from an original cartridge, adding a complex and potentially frustrating step. With a 3,000-page yield and a price of $128.97, it's relatively expensive for a standard-yield cartridge, especially given the chip uncertainty. The 3-year warranty is a positive, but the core product description needs clarification.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Compatible with HP LaserJet Pro M404
- 3,000 page output
- 3-year manufacturer warranty
Cons
- Conflicting chip information (No Chip vs. With Chip)
- Higher price for standard yield
- Potential user complexity if no chip is included
Specifications
- Compatible Brand For HP
- Print Technology Laser
- Color Black
- Compatible Model For HP Toner
- MPN CF258A 58A
- Compatible Model 4 For HP LaserJet M304 Printer
Show all 17 specifications
- Brand
- Oosder
- Type
- Toner Cartridge
- CHIP
- WITH CHIP
- Unit Type
- Unit
- Compatible Printer 2
- For HP LaserJet Pro MFP M428fdw M428fdn
- Compatible Printer 3
- For HP LaserJet Pro MFPM428dw Printer
- Manufacturer Warranty
- 3 Years
- Model
- CF258A
- For Compatible printer model1
- For HP LaserJet Pro M404dn M404dw M404n Printer
- Page Output
- CF258A:UP to 3,000 Pages
- Unit Quantity
- As you selected
