58X Black Toner(No Chip), for HP M404 M404n/dn/dw MFP M428/M428dw/fdw, W258X
This page is affiliate-supported. Prices and availability can change after the last marketplace refresh.
About this product
This Oosder 58X black toner cartridge (W258X) is a compatible high-yield option for HP LaserJet Pro M404 series (M404n/dn/dw) and MFP M428 series (M428dw/fdw, M428fdn) printers, including the M304. It's a laser print technology cartridge with an impressive page output of up to 10,000 pages. Notably, this version is advertised as having "No Chip" but the specs also mention "WITH CHIP." It is covered by a 3-year manufacturer warranty.
Our take
Reviewing this Oosder 58X black toner, the most striking feature is its stated page output of up to 10,000 pages, which offers significant value for frequent monochrome printing. However, there's a critical inconsistency: the title explicitly states "No Chip," while the specs list "CHIP: WITH CHIP." This contradiction makes it difficult to assess true compatibility and ease of installation, as printers often require a chip to function correctly. If it genuinely comes without a chip, users would need to transfer one from an OEM cartridge, which adds a layer of complexity. The 3-year warranty is good, but the chip ambiguity at $133.98 is a major point of concern.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- High page output of 10,000 pages
- 3-year manufacturer warranty
- Compatible with HP LaserJet Pro M404
Cons
- Contradictory chip information (No Chip vs. With Chip)
- Potential installation complexity if no chip
Specifications
- Compatible Brand For HP
- Print Technology Laser
- Color Black
- Compatible Model For HP Toner, CF258X 58X
- MPN CF258A 58A, CF258X 58X
- Compatible Model 4 For HP LaserJet M304 Printer
Show all 17 specifications
- Brand
- Oosder
- Type
- Toner Cartridge
- CHIP
- WITH CHIP
- Unit Type
- Unit
- Compatible Printer 2
- For HP LaserJet Pro MFP M428fdw M428fdn
- Compatible Printer 3
- For HP LaserJet Pro MFPM428dw Printer
- Manufacturer Warranty
- 3 Years
- Model
- CF258X
- For Compatible printer model1
- For HP LaserJet Pro M404dn M404dw M404n Printer
- Page Output
- CF258X:UP to 10,000 Pages
- Unit Quantity
- As you selected
